Your school’s reputation isn’t yours to control


Happy Friday Reader

When a parent describes your school to a friend, what do they actually say?

Not what you hope they say. Not the mission statement or the tagline. What words do they use at the school gate, or over dinner, or in a WhatsApp group you’ll never see?

I spoke this week with Selina Boyd from the Good Schools Guide. Her job is to visit schools and decide whether children are genuinely thriving there. And the way the Good Schools Guide figures that out might surprise you.

It starts before anyone sets foot in the building. Families are spoken to first. Not to tick a box, but because that’s where the real story lives. The team listens for specific words. Belonging. Welcomed. Blossomed. When parents start using language like that unprompted, it signals something no website or prospectus ever could.

Then comes the visit itself, and it’s the small things that matter. Whether a child comes running up to show off a piece of work. Whether older students meet your eye in the corridor and actually want to talk. And Selina’s favourite signal? Walking around with a head who gets treated a bit like a celebrity, because kids keep stopping them to share what they’ve been doing.

That’s not something you can stage.

We also got into what authentic school storytelling actually looks like. And it cuts both ways as a leader. Authentic leadership isn’t what you say about yourself. It’s what others say about you. The parents who can reel off stories about bumping into the head at the school gate. The child who goes home and talks about their teacher. That’s your reputation, whether you’re actively managing it or not.

There’s a dinner party analogy worth borrowing here. If someone spends the whole evening talking about themselves, you switch off. But when someone tells you a story about another person, you lean in. Schools are no different.

The most trusted version of your school’s story isn’t on your website. It’s what your parents say to each other, what your students share, what your staff carry with them outside of work.

The practical bit is straightforward, though most schools miss it. The ones doing this well aren’t just good at marketing. They’re making it easy for other people to speak up. Are your parents in spaces where they naturally talk about you? Do your staff feel comfortable sharing what’s genuinely good? Are your students, especially older ones, given any kind of outlet?

One school Selina visited had a sixth form student who’d found the school himself online, done his own research, and then persuaded his parents it was the right place for him. The school didn’t do that. The story did.

So what does that look like where you are? Who in your community is telling your story, and are you making it easy for them?

Hit reply. I’d genuinely like to know.

Shane

Listen to the latest episode

Click here to listen to this week's episode of my chart-topping podcast, Education Leaders

Education Leaders, 167-169 Great Portland Street, 5th Floor, London, English W1W 5PF
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Education Leaders

Weekly newsletter for education leaders around the world. Expect strategies and reflections on the complexity of school leadership.

Read more from Education Leaders

Happy Friday Reader Elizabeth Newton did a study at Stanford where she split people into tappers and listeners. Tappers had to knock out a well-known song on a table. Happy Birthday, something like that. Listeners had to guess what the song was. The tappers predicted about 50% of listeners would get it right. They could hear the melody in their heads while they were tapping, the words, the tune, all of it. But only in forty people guessed correctly. The listeners only had taps. No melody, no...

Happy Friday Reader This week, i had the pleasure of working with Masters students at St. Mary’s University Belfast, guest lecturing on what makes professional development actually work. We kept coming back to a brilliant framework from the Education Endowment Foundation that breaks effective PD into 14 mechanisms across four areas. Build knowledge. Motivate staff. Develop teaching techniques. Embed practice. All sensible. All evidence-based. When I asked which mechanism is most often missing...

Content Warning: This newsletter discusses school leader mental health challenges, workplace mistreatment, and systemic pressures. Please read with care. It's Friday Reader, and I need to share something with you. I’ve just read Headrest UK’s 2026 Annual Headteacher Wellbeing Report, and I can’t stop thinking about it. Headrest is a volunteer-run support line for school leaders in the UK. Staffed entirely by former headteachers. They started in October 2020 thinking they’d respond to a...